withenAll answers

An honest answer

What Does Detaching With Love Actually Mean?

By Joshua Blair, founder of Withen. He was the one in addiction, seventeen years sober.Published · Updated

What does detaching with love actually mean? It is one of those phrases that gets handed to families with no instructions attached, and I have watched it do damage in the wrong hands.

This is lived experience from one recovery, not medical advice.

I was the one in addiction. Seventeen years sober now, and I have had a long time to think about this phrase, because it was said about my family.

What it actually means

Detaching with love means letting go of the outcome. It does not mean letting go of the person.

It means you stop trying to manage someone else's using. You stop steering, covering, predicting, fixing. You put down the part that was never in your hands to begin with.

You do not stop loving them. You do not go cold. That is the entire reason the words "with love" are in there.

What it does not mean

It does not mean cutting someone off to teach them a lesson. That is a different thing wearing the same coat.

It does not mean silence as punishment. It does not mean pretending you have stopped caring. And it does not require you to feel calm about any of it. You can let go of the outcome and still be scared out of your mind. Those two live together fine.

How it gets used wrong

People say it to families who are already drowning, and they say it as though it means stop caring so much. Sometimes it is a polite way of telling someone they are the problem.

In my experience the people quickest to hand over the phrase are rarely the ones offering to help carry anything.

If someone gives you this and what they mean is that you are too involved, you are allowed to notice they have given you a rule and no support. That is not detaching with love. That is just leaving, with better wording.

Where the phrase comes from

It is most associated with Al-Anon, the fellowship for the families and friends of alcoholics, and it has been handed around for decades since, in meetings and in books. I am not affiliated with Al-Anon and I can't speak for them. What I can tell you is what the phrase looked like from the receiving end.

What it looked like from my side

My family stopped funding the addiction. They stopped smoothing it over. That was the letting go, and I felt it.

What they did not do was disappear. I always knew where they were.

That distinction is the whole thing, and I would put it above any phrase. They let go of controlling what I did, and they stayed reachable while they did it. When my moment finally came, somebody was still standing there. That only worked because they had not burned themselves down or vanished in the meantime.

With a child, and with a spouse

I was somebody's child, not somebody's husband, so I can only tell you the parent side from the inside. For my mom, letting go of the outcome meant she stopped rescuing and never stopped being my mom. Those turned out to be two different things.

If it is your husband or your wife, you share a roof and a bank account and maybe children, and letting go of the outcome has edges that a parent's version doesn't. I won't pretend otherwise. What I can say is that the principle held in my family either way: stop managing the using, stay a person they can find. And if anything in your house ever comes with fear of the person you love, this phrase is not for that. In the US, the National Domestic Violence Hotline is 1-800-799-7233, or text START to 88788. Safety comes first, every time.

This is my story, not a formula

That is what it looked like around one recovery. It is not a guarantee about yours.

And if you had to go further than that, if you had to block the number and go quiet in order to survive, that was survival. It was not a failure to detach correctly. There is no correct.

If things are heavy right now

In the US, SAMHSA's free helpline is 1-800-662-4357, open 24/7, for treatment questions and for family support. In Canada, 211 connects you with addiction services in your province. If you or someone you love is in crisis, call or text 988, any time. It works in the US and Canada.

Why Withen exists

My family got the phrase and nothing else. Nobody explaining it, nobody checking on them afterward. Withen is the place I am building for the people in that position. It opens soon, and the waitlist is at joinwithen.com.

Questions people ask

What are examples of detaching with love?

Not paying for the addiction, and saying so plainly. Not lying to cover for them. Letting a consequence land that was theirs. Still answering the phone. Still telling them you love them. Still eating dinner, sleeping, and seeing your own friends. None of those is cold. All of them are letting go of the outcome.

Is detaching with love the same as cutting someone off?

No. Cutting someone off to teach them a lesson is a different thing wearing the same coat. Detaching with love keeps the person and drops the outcome. If you had to go further than that to survive, that was survival, and there is no correct.

How do I detach with love when I worry all the time?

You can let go of the outcome and still be scared out of your mind. Those two live together fine. The worry was never what kept me alive, which is the part that lets you put the job down. I wrote about that here.

Something you can use tonight.

A free guide from Josh: what to say when they ask you for money. It lands in your inbox right away, and you'll hear first when Withen opens.

You're sharing your email with us. We use it only to send the guide and Josh's updates, and we never sell it. We take reasonable care, but no system is perfectly secure. By signing up you confirm you're 18 or older. Privacy policy

One email with the guide, one when Withen opens. Unsubscribe any time.

Read more answers